Weekly book reviews by the three of us - Adèle Geras, Linda Newbery and Celia Rees - and our guests, all writers or independent booksellers, with occasional special features. We choose our own recommendations: fiction, non-fiction, memoirs, nature writing; in fact anything other than children's books, and not necessarily newly-published. We hope you'll enjoy our selections, and keep coming back for more. Follow us on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter - @writersreview1.
Monday, 10 April 2017
Guest review by Catherine Butler: THIS EARLY DARK: MICRO-POETRY AND ULTRA-FLASH FICTION by Michael Cadnum
Catherine Butler is Senior Lecturer in English Literature at Cardiff University, where her academic books on children’s literature include Four British Fantasists (Scarecrow/ ChLA, 2006), and Reading History in Children’s Books (with Hallie O’Donovan; Palgrave, 2012).She has also produced numerous novels for children and teenagers, as well as some shorter works, of which the latest is Twisted Winter (A&C Black, 2013).
Michael Cadnum is a prolific author of both novels and
poetry, and I’ve long been one of his admirers. As its title suggests, the
contents of This Early Dark include
both fiction and poems; however, since both are reduced to highly concentrated
bouillon cubes, it is hard at times to say which is which. Very short poems and
extremely short fictions, consisting of two or three lines apiece, are
scattered through its pages. This is the slimmest of slim volumes, but it
contains multitudes. Cadnum’s novels are poetic, and his poems, even when
short, often contain a seed of narrative that could quite happily be coaxed to
novel length. Just add water – or wonder.
Some of Cadnum’s work has a specificity that is reminiscent
of William Carlos Williams, or indeed the haiku tradition that so inspired the
Imagists. They take a familiar and “ordinary” experience, and pebble-polish it:
How lovely, the
wrinkled tablecloth now that everyone’s gone.
This image pulls our gaze to it, but does not ask us to look
beyond itself. Sometimes, though, the poet notices himself noticing: “I realize
the book is reading me and I close it”. Or, a little less unsettlingly:
If we could stay like this--
trying forever to
start his car.
The promise of poetry is that we can stay like this, that moments can be pinned like moths, or
framed like photographs. Except that poetry works in more dimensions than two, drawing
on all the senses and their attendant moods.
Memory, absence and regret are prominent in many of the
pieces here, and rain seeps through much of the collection, far more than one
would expect from a writer who has lived much of his life in California: “Years
after the cat is gone shadows everywhere wash themselves”; “I found your
cigarettes in the suitcase and wake with your cough”; “I thought you touched me
but it was the rain”. Often, the particularity of experience gestures towards metaphor:
After dark I wish I had not cut off
so many branches.
Is this the small-hours fretting of an overenthusiastic gardener,
or of someone who has been too profligate with life’s possibilities? (Both, of
course.) Occasionally, there is a proverbial quality to Cadnum’s lines, as well
as an observational one:
Only when it’s gone does the
passing jet whisper.
Cadnum is a novelist, and often the ghost of a story, or the
embryo of one, peeps from his words, teasing us to wonder what happened just
after, or just before:
Soapsuds across the carpet where
you left the bath to watch him leave.
The pieces were written over a forty-year period, but it is
not clear whether they are arranged in anything resembling chronological order:
the quality of Cadnum’s perceptions appears consistent throughout. Intimate
relationships with people, with nature, with things, thoughts and feelings
wheel through its pages, winking in and out like stars. I am not certain of
Cadnum’s working method, although perhaps it is expressed in one of the shorter
pieces here: “I burn the words to make them happen”. In any case, This Early Dark is a valuable and
This Early Dark is published by CreateSpace and as a Kindle edition.